In the firelit back room of an old Oxford pub, a circle of tweedy dons sits round a table of pints and books, two of them leaning together in delighted recognition, a dog asleep by the hearth.

Original artwork, not a still

C.S. Lewis

Friendship is born at the moment when one person says to another "What! You too? I thought that no one but myself."

Behind the line

What it means

Our interpretation.

Lewis is describing the click you feel on finding another person who loves the odd thing you thought only you loved: the obscure book, the strange hobby, the cult film. That is why fans reach for it so often; it explains fandom in a sentence, and every convention, forum and group chat is a version of that first "you too?". It is also the line people quote when they want to say friendship is about shared truth, not shared company.

Context reviewed

In context

May contain spoilersShow the scene

C. S. Lewis wrote it in The Four Loves (1960), in the chapter on Friendship (Ch. IV), where he separates friendship from the other loves. Lovers, he says, are absorbed in each other, while friends stand side by side, absorbed in some shared interest or insight that each believed was his alone. The moment of discovery is the birth of the friendship. In the book the sentence trails off in an ellipsis after "no one but myself", and Lewis offers a plainer paraphrase of the same moment nearby.

Sources (1)

Context reviewed

Share this quote